No items found.
essays

The Pull of the Good

August 7, 2025
Even if we can agree on what counts as right, there is still the question of why we should care. The answer may lie in the way moral action shapes our lives, not only in its effect on others.

subscribe to unlock this article and all others.

subscribe now

Already a subscriber? Sign in.

The thought that we could ignore morality without consequence is tempting to some. If there were no punishment or reward, why not take the easier road? Yet this way of framing the question may miss what moral action does for the person who chooses it. Acting justly can foster a sense of coherence between our values and our behaviour. It can create a steadiness in character that self-interest alone rarely produces.

Some see moral motivation as rooted in human connection. When we recognise others as part of our moral world, their suffering matters to us in ways that go beyond calculation. Acting rightly then becomes an expression of that concern, a way of affirming the kind of community we want to live in.

Others think the force of morality lies in its demands on reason. If we accept certain principles as binding, consistency requires that we follow them, even when they conflict with immediate desires. In this view, doing the right thing is a commitment to being guided by reasons we can stand behind, not just impulses we happen to feel.

There is also the idea that moral action is valuable for its own sake. A life lived without regard for fairness, honesty, or compassion may secure short-term advantage, but it risks eroding trust, respect, and self-respect. Over time, such a life can feel hollow, even to its apparent beneficiary.

The motivation to do what is right may draw from all these sources: a wish for harmony within oneself, a concern for others, a respect for reasoned principles, and an appreciation for the worth of virtue itself. Philosophy’s role is to make us aware of these currents so we can steer by them deliberately, rather than drift into a morality defined by habit or convenience.

Main image: Marc Chagall – The Walk

No items found.